Documentary filmmaker Jacob Young (The Dancing Outlaw) introduces viewers to a Kentucky man who believes the unidentified artifact he purchased from a local Goodwill store is in fact a religious artifact with the power to inspire divine visions. When Todd Walker spotted the unusual item at the Goodwill store, he was immediately drawn to it. Later, after returning home, he began to meditate on the object and found his mind flooded with a series of fantastical, sometime frightening, images. Before long Todd is convinced that he's managed to acquire a Biblical artifact known as Urim and Thummim that's said to inspire wisdom and divination in anyone who comes into contact with it. But does the artifact truly possess mystical powers, as Todd claims, or is its latest owner simply seeing what he wants to?