Todd (Jonathan Bray) goes on a coffee date set up by his brother, but finds that he's the butt of a practical joke. The woman named Kelly he's supposed to meet is actually a gay man. As revenge, the pair pretend to be a real couple. The scope of the ruse widens when Todd's mother learns the news and goes out of her way to support her now out-of-the-closet son. While some of Todd's friends are surprised, others say they knew all along -- prompting Todd to wonder if maybe the joke is on him.